“Alex, we brought that shirt you asked for,” Lexi said with a sly smile as she and Ruby walked into my apartment, their eyes locked on me with that familiar teasing spark. Damn, my wife Lily’s cousins had a way of making even a quick drop-off feel loaded with tension.
“One shirt, and you both had to come? Must’ve been a hassle,” I said, trying to keep it light even as my pulse kicked up.
Lexi laughed softly and gave my ass a quick smack. “If it was just one of us, you’d probably try something, huh? So, who would you want showing up alone—me or Ruby?”
“Stop that,” I muttered, quickly changing into the new shirt before things escalated. “What about the missing button on this one? Lily’s gonna ask questions. It was you who pulled it off, wasn’t it, Lexi?”
“Alex, why do you always pin it on me? Ruby did it—tell him, sis.”
“Ruby, that was you?” I asked, watching her look away, her face turning pink. She nodded quietly. “Didn’t expect that from you. You seem so chill, but get going and you’re intense. Nice.” She blushed harder, avoiding my eyes—who knew she could get this embarrassed?
Lexi grinned. “You’re still getting all red? I saw you do it without hesitating. Kinda late for that now.”
They were about to start bickering again, so I cut in. “Who can fix a button? Let’s handle it before Lily notices—I’m bad at lying about this stuff.”
“I got it,” Ruby said softly, taking the shirt and pulling out a button from her pocket. She’d brought needle and thread too. She was definitely more on top of things than Lexi, and watching her stitch it up so smoothly? Impressive.
“See, Lexi? She’s got skills. You couldn’t do that.”
Lexi frowned, then stepped close, her lips suddenly on mine in a surprise kiss. Her hand went straight to my crotch, gripping me through my jeans. “But I kiss better,” she whispered, making it deep and slow, her tongue teasing mine until I felt lightheaded. “Ruby can’t touch that.”
“Wanna bet?” Ruby pushed her aside, wrapping her arms around my neck and kissing me hard. Her lips were soft, moving against mine for what felt like ages—at least thirty seconds. It was addictive; she had this quiet heat that pulled you in deeper than Lexi’s boldness.
Ruby had my mouth, but Lexi kept her hand on my dick, which was getting harder by the second. They took turns with the kisses, each one lasting longer, getting messier. Ruby’s last one went on for four or five minutes, leaving us both breathing heavy. When Lexi moved in again, I had to stop.
“Wait, hold on. You’re switching off like it’s nothing, but I’m the one dealing with both of you. Give me a second to breathe—unless you want Lily dealing with this alone.”
Ruby smirked at Lexi, like she’d won with the longer kiss. Lexi pouted, then realized her hand was still there. “I’ve had my hand on him longer than you. Beat that.”
Ruby reached over too, but I stepped back. “Hey, I’m not here for you to fight over. First kisses, now this? Let’s just grab everything and go.”
They turned on me together. “Whatever. We were just messing around. Touching you was basically a favor—for Lily.”
I ignored it and got us out of there, feeling like I was dodging something big with them trailing behind. Back home, Lily was on the couch, remote in hand. “You all came in at the same time?”
“Yeah, ran into each other downstairs,” we said in unison. Lily didn’t question it—she trusted me too much for that.
I stayed calm, but the girls were flushed. Lily noticed. “You look overheated. Want me to turn on the AC?”
“No,” they both said quickly. “Alex says not to run it all the time.”
Lily gave us a look. “When did he say that? You’re acting different today, quoting him like that. Did he get on your case?”
Relief hit me. She thought I was just being tough on them, not that anything else was going on. We got past it.
That night, Lily pressed against me in bed. “Work’s got this trip coming up. You’ll look after the girls? Don’t be too hard on them.”
Hearing she’d be gone gave me this unexpected buzz—I’d never felt that way before about her leaving. I’d always worried about her out there alone, looking like she does. But now? Part of me wanted the space. “What if they come after me? Climb in here? I’d handle it.”
“You wouldn’t,” she said with a laugh. “You talk big, but you’d back out. They’re right next door—go ahead if you think you can. Probably not even wearing much.”
“Not unless you leave me exhausted tonight.”
“Try me. I’ll wear you out, or I’ll sleep on the floor.”
I moved on her, already hard from the day’s buildup. I’d come earlier from Lexi’s touch, but it wasn’t enough—nothing like being inside.
“Door’s not closed all the way.”
“Forget it. They’re asleep. You stalling because you can’t take it?”
Lily held back at first with them nearby, but after a few thrusts, she let go.
“Oh… oh… yeah… yeah… harder… like that… ah… fuck… mmm… so good… ah… you’re so big… ah… filling me up… mmm… it’s so tight… feels amazing… mmm… squeeze you… mmm… uh… grab my tits… ah… yes… fuck me… harder… shh… faster… oh god…”
Her sounds were raw, but my mind kept drifting to Ruby and Lexi, their bodies. It distracted me—her moans even started to irritate.
Then the door creaked. She didn’t hear, too caught up, but I caught the breathing outside. They were watching. It turned me on—no failing now.
“Lily, you’re so wet. Ready for me to fuck you?”
“Shut up! Get in there.”
I thrust deep, pulled out, slammed back, grunting with each one.
I paused sometimes, tip at her entrance, so they could see how thick I was—bigger than before.
It drove her crazy, hips moving to take me. She got louder—probably woke the block.
“Mmm… uh… you’re the best… so big… mmm… fuck… deeper… ah… I’m coming… ah… fast…”
I talked back, thinking of them, imagining it was the cousins.
“Mmm… my cock feels good… so tight… oh…”
“Ah… harder… I’m losing it… mmm…”
“Lily, you like it? You little slut?”
“Mmm… you’re killing me… so thick… hard… my pussy’s on fire… ah… I’m there… coming…”
The sounds outside got heavier—I didn’t want her noticing. I went harder, grinding deep.
“Babe, Lily, I’m coming—filling you up.” After more thrusts, I came hard inside her.
She felt it. “So much… hot… it’s overflowing… sheets again…”
I covered her, flashing a thumbs-up at the door. They knew I’d seen them.
They slipped away, probably couldn’t sleep after that.
